Virtual ​Library
  • Library
    • About the library >
      • Teacher Librarians
      • Book Week Celebrations
      • Blind Date with a Book
    • Book Week 2022 Events
    • Oliver Library
    • Book Trailers
    • Premier's Reading Challenge
    • Join NSW State Library >
      • Online Membership Application - State Library
      • NSW State Library E-resources
  • Information Fluency
    • Infowhelm
    • Digital Citizenship >
      • Introduction - Our Digital Life
      • Cybersafety
      • Cyberbullying
      • Copyright and Fair Dealing
      • Digital Footprint
    • Critical Thinking
    • Research Process >
      • Initiate >
        • Deciding on a Research Topic
      • Locate >
        • Online Search Techniques
      • Select >
        • Evaluating Sources
        • Primary vs Secondary Sources
      • Organise
      • Present
      • Assess
    • Self-reflection for metacognition
    • Note Taking & Summarising
    • Plagiarism
    • Referencing
    • Paraphrasing
    • Annotated Bibliography
    • Mind Maps for note taking and brainstorming
  • Curriculum
    • ATSI Education >
      • The Aboriginal 8 Ways of Learning Pedagogy
    • Prelim & HSC >
      • SMH 2019 HSC Study Guide
      • English Prelim & HSC >
        • HSC Common Module - Texts and Human Experiences
        • English Standard Module A - Language, Identity and Culture
        • Standard Module B: Close Study of Literature
        • English Advanced Module A: Textual Conversations
        • Advanced Module B: Critical Study of Literature
        • Advanced Module C: The Craft of Writing
        • Post Colonial Literature
      • Maths Prelim & HSC
      • Science Prelim & HSC >
        • Biology
        • Chemistry
        • Earth and Environmental Science
        • Physics
      • HSIE Prelim & HSC >
        • Aboriginal Studies
        • Ancient History
        • Business Studies
        • Economics
        • Geography Prelim & HSC
        • Legal Studies
        • Modern History
        • Society and Culture
      • CAPA Prelim & HSC >
        • Dance
        • Drama
        • Music
        • Visual Arts
      • PDHPE - Prelim & HSC
      • TAS Prelim & HSC >
        • CAFS Community and Family Studies
        • Food Technology
    • 7 - 10 Subject Areas >
      • English 7-10
      • Maths 7-10
      • Science 7-10
      • HSIE 7-10
      • CAPA 7-10
      • PDHPE 7-10
      • TAS 7-10
    • Trove
  • Learning Tools
    • PEEL Paragraph Writing
    • Academic writing
    • A.L.A.R.M.
    • A Glossary of NESA Key Words
    • SQ3R Reading 4 Understanding
    • Bloom's Taxonomy
    • How to study effectively
    • Learning, your brain and Neuroscience
    • Memorising and Mnemonics
    • Mind Maps for note taking and brainstorming
    • PMI Plus, Minus, Interesting Strategy
    • What is your learning preference?
  • Inspiration

Evaluating Sources

11/3/2016

0 Comments

 
Evaluating Information Sources 
It is important that we understand that not all information is equal. We need to be selective when it comes to information sources. Just because you find it in print or online, do not assume that it is accurate or reliable. It is shown that students have difficulty determining fact from opinion and need help sharpening their critical thinking skills when using and evaluating information sources (Hough 2011; OECD 2011).


Primary Verses Secondary Sources
The most important point to note when using information sources is that primary sources are most reliable.

What's the difference?
Primary Source: A first-hand, original account, record, or evidence about a person, place, object, or an event. Examples of primary sources: Oral histories, objects, photographs, and documents such as newspapers, ledgers, census records, diaries, journals, and inventories, scientific reports and results of experiments.

Secondary Source: An account, record, or evidence derived from an original or primary source. Examples of secondary sources: Textbooks, analysis of a clinical trial, biographies, newspaper articles that interpret, publications about the significance of research or experiments.
 

Criteria for Evaluating Information Sources
Picture
What is the PURPOSE of the source?
Is it to inform, to present opinions, to report research or to sell a product? For what audience is it intended: general public? children? scholars?
 
Is the information RELEVANT or suitable for my purpose?
Is the information relevant to the question at hand? Is the information suitable to my age and academic level? Is the depth of coverage adequate?

Who is the AUTHOR?
Are the author's qualifications or experience given? Are they an expert in their field? What credentials or special knowledge does he/she have? Does the author have a certain bias? Are references provided?

Who is the PUBLISHER?
Is it published by an academic institution such as a university? Is the information published by a government agency or by a large commercial publisher, a non-profit organisation or a business? The publisher may give clues as to the reliability and/or bias of the information presented. What does the URL tell you?

How CURRENT or up to date is this information?
Are the statistics and facts cited in the source up to date? Is it current? Is there a "last updated" date shown on the web page?

Is the information ACCURATE?  Should I believe this information? What authority does it have?
Does it contain documented facts or personal opinion? Is bias evident? Are there any footnotes, bibliographies, or lists of references that let you check the accuracy of statistics or factual information? Is the documentation from published sources or personal webpages?
 
What can I tell from an Internet address?


Looking at URL of a website (.com  .edu  .org  .gov  etc.)  will often tell you something about what kind of website you're visiting. This provides a clue about how trustworthy or objective the information might be. 

Examples of sources that are often the most credible: 
  • Official government websites
  • Institutional sites that represent universities, regulatory agencies, governing bodies, and respected organisations with specific expertise
  • Peer-reviewed journals
  • Reputable news sources


To find out more and to take the online quiz see:
http://www.virtuallibrary.info/evaluating-sources.html

 
References and further reading

California State University. (2010) Evaluating Information – Applying the CRAAP Test. Retrieved from: http://www.csuchico.edu/lins/handouts/eval_websites.pdf

Gettysburg College. (2014) How to Evaluate Resources. Retrieved from:
http://www.gettysburg.edu/library/research/tips/webeval/index.dot

Hough, M. (2011). Libraries as iCentres: Helping Schools. ACCESS, 25(1) 5-9.
 
OECD (2011), Pisa 2009 Results: Students online: Digital Technologies and Performance, (Volume VI). Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development. Retrieved from: http://www.ecdl.org/media/PISA_2009_Results.pdf

Teacher Tap. (2013) Evaluating Internet Sources. Retrieved from:
http://eduscapes.com/tap/topic32.htm

Virginia Tech. (2014) Evaluating internet information. Retrieved from:
http://www.lib.vt.edu/instruct/evaluate/
 

Cathy Costello 2015
0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Cathy Costello  -
    ​Teacher Librarian, Information Specialist and lifelong learner.


    ​Available for public speaking, professional development training focusing on topics and concepts addressed here and in my 
    ​www.virtuallibrary.info website.

    Picture
    All opinions are my own
    Follow Virtual Library
    ​on Facebook

    Categories

    All
    21C
    Advocacy
    Australian Curriculum
    Constructivist Learning
    Critical Thinking
    EBP
    Evaluating Sources
    Evidence Based Practice
    Graphic Novels
    Information Literacy
    Literacy
    The Role Of The Teacher Librarian

    Archives

    August 2017
    November 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016

    Cathy Costello teacher librarian virtual library Cathy Costello teacher librarian virtual library Cathy Costello library Cathy Costello virtual library Cathy Costello librarian

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.